Bookgeeks is part of the Bookswarm Network

If The Dead Rise Not, by Philip Kerr

By on February 24, 2010

The sixth but to my mind the least successful of Philip Kerr’s fantastic Bernie Gunther series.

As has been the way since Bernie Gunther’s return in A Quiet Flame, the action in If The Dead Rise Not is split between Berlin in the 30s and Latin America in the 1950s. Gunther is still a hugely engaging character, a German Philip Marlowe, forced out of the police for being unable to keep his smart alec mouth in check. Still around because he’s good and can just about keep his head above water. Other people’s heads are a different matter entirely.

The first two thirds are set in the prestigious Hotel Adlon where Gunther is the house detective during the build up to the Berlin Olympics. The usual run of theft and prostitution is disrupted by the arrival of a gregariously dangerous American and the Berlin Olympic organising commitee, in town to divvy up construction contracts.

A committee member is found dead in a hotel room. Bernie is then asked as a favour to a ranking Nazi to identify another dead body pulled from the Landswehr canal. This body turns out to be that of a construction worker on the Olympic site. Investigating the connections brings Bernie face to face with the bestial regime and the dangerous American. Not to mention the girl. There’s always the girl.

Fast forward twenty years and Gunther is living quietly under an assumed name in Batista’s Cuba before the revolution. Who is that he sees in the local bookshop?

If The Dead Rise Not is superior crime fiction and makes for a highly entertaining read, but the brush strokes are that bit broader, the story a tad more predictable and the settings less convincingly real. Has the series settled into the formulaic? If we are in Cuba in the 50s does it have to be at Hemingway’s house? Does the detail owe more to a cultural memory of The Godfather Part 2 than to primary research?

Certainly Philip Kerr seems more determined to hold the audience’s hand, less inclined to make us work for our pleasures. For me there’s a little too much spoon-feeding exposition, more playing to the gallery, less confidence in the reader. Not something previously seen in earlier Bernie Gunther books but perhaps apparent in other Philip Kerrs.

The result is a curious half way house between an airport thriller and more psychological fare. A million miles better than a puerile Michael Dobbs, but falling short of the heights Kerr has already set with the same character. Perhaps this is simply an example of the ambivalence we feel when a private pleasure becomes public, because Bernie Gunther has certainly crossed over and Philip Kerr is not short of recognition for this achievement. I still love the series as a whole and hope this is a simple blipette rather than a more fundamental change in direction.

One Comment on If The Dead Rise Not, by Philip Kerr

  1. Craig Schultz on Sat, 3rd Apr 2010 8:40 pm
  2. I came across this site randomly while checking reviews of P. Kerr’s latest.
    Your comments are spot on about all of his works. Thanks for the insights.

Let us know your thoughts below